News

By Jessica Yadegaran SFGATE Food Editor

To understand why the East Bay’s first Original Joe’s has been so embraced by its community, a restaurant where the weeknight waiting area is as packed as an urgent care and its bouncers — a rarity at typical red-sauce joints — earn tips they’ve never seen in their lives, you need to go back to the beginning.

The Duggans, the family behind the classic San Francisco restaurant of 89 years, invested eight years and millions of dollars to debut the 300-seat destination last year in Walnut Creek. The upscale suburb is a red-hot market where new business licenses are up 21% year over year. On opening day, Aug. 14, Mayor Cindy Darling cut the ribbon around 10:45 a.m. Media swarmed the entrance, hoping to get a glimpse of the priest blessing every room with holy water. By 11 a.m., when the gold-handled doors opened, a line of patrons had already formed outside.

“To see it come to fruition in front of us is very fulfilling,” co-owner John Duggan said to me over the crowd that day. “It’s lived up to what we thought it could be. The East Bay has been waiting for something like this for a long time.”

Then, four days later, a mysterious late-night fire erupted in the kitchen. It took fire crews hours to even determine the source. (It was inside a wall.) The restaurant reported only smoke damage and planned to return to business “within a week,” they told KGO-TV, but ultimately remained closed for six weeks.

Then, finally, on Oct. 1, the classic Italian restaurant known for giant portions and multigenerational diners reopened its doors for good this time.

And it has been an absolute zoo ever since.

“This is Original Joe’s on steroids,” security guard Louis Wright, who has been with the company for 10 years, told me on a recent Wednesday night, when the wait was nearly an hour. “I get more tips here than I did in the city.”

Dressed in a dapper three-piece, pin-striped suit, Wright recounted the story of a happy customer who handed him $250 for doing his job, which includes bussing tables and manning the host stand. Gesturing to the marble floors, emerald-green leather booths and spacious lobby, Wright said, “It’s something about the ambiance. It just feels like Vegas.”

Much of the allure of Original Joe’s — and the reason this community has embraced it so much — is the nostalgia. People who moved from San Francisco to the suburbs, like me, remember hourslong, hearty meals and family gatherings at the North Beach flagship, as well as carving into chicken parmigiana the size of a placemat.

The Walnut Creek location has its own showstopper: a tower of zucchini fries, which arrive with the fanfare of a three-tier cake. It comes from the Duggans’ restaurant Little Original Joe’s in San Francisco, where it’s also a fan favorite.

“Look at that thing,” my dining companion cooed when ours hit the table, a heap of translucent, lightly fried green crispiness showered in too much parmigiana reggiano ($18.95). The lack of grease and the addition of lemon basil aioli helped us reduce the mountain to a hill in minutes.

Entrees at Original Joe’s — not just at the flagship in North Beach but also at the Daly City and Walnut Creek locations — are made with a bigger-is-better ethos. The lightly breaded, fiercely pounded chicken parmigiana ($37.95) of my SF memories is still a signature dish. So big it’s served on a platter, it took me three days to finish after taking leftovers home.

It’s been so hard to score a table since the reopening that most diners we talked to said it was nearly impossible to get in for the first two months. Back in December, I tried to get a 6 p.m. reservation, and the soonest table available was in mid-January.

Given the size of the property and what they called “the encouraging customer response so far,” the Duggans told me that the Walnut Creek spot has the potential to be the busiest of the three Original Joe’s locations.

“Guests keep telling us it feels like we’ve always been here, or they’ve found a new ‘home,’ and that’s really the highest compliment we could get,” they said.

On Wednesday night, Maya Villasenor and Kaleah Rivero of San Leandro walked in and were seated immediately at the long, open kitchen counter right under a giant, brightly lit Walnut Creek sign. The wait for a table or booth was an hour, they were told, but turnover in those eight diner-style swivel stools is much faster.

Villasenor had been wanting to bring Rivero to Original Joe’s since it opened, but the fire delayed her plans. “It became this dog-ate-my-homework type thing because she was like, ‘Oh there was a fire, huh? What happened to that date night you promised me?’” Villasenor said, laughing. Ultimately, their first time at an Original Joe’s lived up to the hype and videos they’d seen on Instagram. “It’s so cute in here,” Rivero said. “We’ll definitely be back.”

Back at my table, I sink into an espresso martini as only Joe’s can make it: Tito’s vodka and coffee brewed from SF’s iconic Graffeo beans and punched up with every liqueur that could possibly go with coffee — not only Kahlúa but also Baileys, Frangelico and butterscotch-tinged Tuaca — for an over-the-top yet somehow perfectly classic cocktail. Vegas, baby.

Editor’s note: This story originally ran online Jan. 28, 2026, and has been edited for print.

Jessica Yadegaran is the food editor at SFGATE.

View Article